Customer choice has narrowed – the FCA could help fix this
02 Nov 2015
Last month what has become known as ‘the toughest job interview on television’, The Apprentice, began. For starters, I can’t honestly think of another job interview on television so it was always bound to win that accolade, which leaves me wondering what sort of competition we will witness. I’m suspecting that, much like previous years, there will be an assortment of competent people thrown together with what might politely be described as ‘wannabes’. It’s relatively entertaining and no doubt will include its fair share of good ideas thrown together with some of the most idiotic nonsense you could ever wish to see on the TV.
This type of competition appears to be a long way from the competition we all come up against in business. Our everyday working life may not be as ‘dog eat dog’ or acutely personal as that shown on The Apprentice, but there is certainly a lot to consider, a lot to overcome, and (quite frankly) a lot to worry about.
Of course competition is a fact of life and, let’s be fair, without it we would be unlikely to strive and push for greater excellence or to improve our service and product offering. Given that we are already players within the marketplace, we may well feel that it is an open road to travel in order to be active in our sector, however, this might not be the case for all. Indeed, if we think about our own business journeys to the point where we sit today, how many times did the obstacles appear insurmountable or incredibly challenging. Perhaps too much so?
Breaking down barriers
That will certainly be one of the views the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) might wish to consider when it opens its study into mortgage market competition, and whether it is a ‘closed shop’ or ‘overly hard’ to move into this space. Certainly, for every sub-sector of the market that appears to be resplendent with lender and product choice, there will be others where the options are few and far between. Why should that be? What barriers have been raised which make this the apparent status quo?
From the perspective of a mortgage adviser, I would be surprised not to hear any number of experiences, especially since the Mortgage Market Review has meant clients simply do not have anywhere near the choice they once had. We’re not talking about markets such as heavy sub-prime either, which have all but disappeared in the post-credit crunch fall-out, but areas which should ordinarily offer significant product choice – interest-only, lending into retirement, mortgages for the self-employed and contractors – but do not seem to do so.
A market ‘fit for purpose’
What are the reasons for this? Is market regulation, albeit needed, having an overtly detrimental effect on the ability of existing lenders to compete in these spaces? Are new offerings – banks, challengers, specialists – having to jump through too many hoops in order to bring a proposition to market? Do we simply not have the accessible funding necessary in order to develop these proposition ideas further? And when they do get to market, is there no other option but to go to the limited, specialist, higher margin product areas, as opposed to attempt a more mass-market appeal?
This review will certainly have to be wide-ranging in its brief and its deed. Especially if we are to develop a mortgage market which is not just fit for purpose now but offers choice and opportunity much further down the line. Increased competition is certainly key in that respect, and while we have seen this improve in certain parts of the market over the last 12 months, the regulator may need to play its part in helping develop a far more accessible marketplace across the board in the months and years to come.

Blog Archive
Uncertainty continues into 2021
07 Jan 2021
Stay ahead of the fraudsters
21 Dec 2020
Industry change starts with what we do ourselves and within our businesses
11 Dec 2020
Second lockdown will keep lender resource focused on payment deferrals
09 Nov 2020
Is now the right time to add to property portfolios?
08 Sep 2020
Advisers have duty of care as fraudsters step up scam activity
17 Aug 2020
IFAs and mortgage advisers – two sides of the same coin
12 Aug 2020
Brokers need fair play from lenders in high LTV space
31 Jul 2020
Are you ready for lock-stalgia?
03 Jul 2020
Show your clients what you can do
19 Jun 2020
Specialist lenders may need end to self-cert payment holidays to survive
16 Jun 2020
Reading the signals
15 Jun 2020
Is the FCA really in this with us?
28 May 2020
Self-employed people must not be locked out of future mortgage borrowing
11 May 2020
I wish I could say the worst is over
07 Apr 2020
Looking for scintillating letters of recommendation
11 Mar 2020
FCA must answer why it is promoting execution-only
25 Feb 2020
Goodbye doesn’t have to be forever
17 Feb 2020
FCA changes could have harmful consequences
07 Feb 2020
This could be the year of economic stimulation
03 Feb 2020
Putting the cart before the horse
17 Jan 2020
The start of a new decade
15 Jan 2020
The importance of advice
12 Dec 2019
Keep in touch with clients or lose them for good
06 Dec 2019
Later life market still needs work to be fit for purpose
22 Nov 2019
Helping mortgage prisoners
04 Nov 2019
Combatting mortgage fraud
20 Sep 2019
Upping demand for green mortgages
17 Jul 2019
Tory leadership hopefuls are right to be focused on social care in later life
01 Jul 2019
Responding to political messages about the housing market
20 Jun 2019
Promoting execution-only is not treating customers fairly
10 Jun 2019
Changing regulatory permissions can be the making of your business
14 May 2019
If we don’t talk up the market, then who will?
02 May 2019
Deeper product transfer data would show lenders’ market shifts
29 Mar 2019
Mortgage Market Study inconsistencies make for frustrating read
27 Mar 2019
The relationship between lender, broker and borrower
18 Feb 2019
Advisers must not leave mainstream mortgage market to lenders
28 Jan 2019
Let’s not blow Fleet and Secure Trust Bank out of proportion
17 Jan 2019
‘Regulation should not be reworked purely to support automated advisers’
04 Jan 2019